Weaver Leather Supply Review
Quick Take: Weaver Leather Supply is one of the most complete leathercraft suppliers in the US market. Based in Mount Hope, Ohio, they carry leather, hardware, tools, machines, and supplies in a catalog deep enough to cover most makers from first project to full production. The community rates them as a reliable step up from Tandy, with strong hardware selection and a wholesale program for volume buyers.
Maker Angle: Weaver is the supplier you go to when you need everything in one place and you want to know it will actually ship. The hardware catalog is a particular strength – broad selection, consistent stock, and competitive pricing. The machines section carries the red Weaver machines that serious production makers recognize. If you are building a business and need a supplier who can grow with you, Weaver is worth a serious look.
Quick Jump
Fast Links
Shop Weaver Leather Supply | Sale / Deals | Returns | Wholesale / Volume Pricing | Machines
Maker Notes
Weaver Leather Supply has been a fixture in the leathercraft supply market for decades. Based in Mount Hope, Ohio, they operate a retail store in Holmes County and a full e-commerce operation that ships nationwide. The catalog covers leather, hardware, tools, machines, dyes, finishes, and supplies – a depth that makes them one of the few single-source options for makers who want to reduce the number of suppliers they manage.
The hardware catalog is a particular strength. Makers who have worked through multiple suppliers consistently come back to Weaver for hardware because the selection is broad, the stock is reliable, and the pricing is competitive at volume. The wholesale program – available to qualifying buyers – adds another layer of value for makers who have moved into production. The machines section carries the red Weaver machines that have become a recognized standard in serious leathercraft shops.
Best For
- Hardware sourcing: One of the deepest hardware catalogs in the US market. Buckles, rivets, snaps, D-rings, Chicago screws – broad selection and reliable stock.
- One-stop orders: Leather, hardware, tools, and supplies in one order from one supplier. Fewer shipments, less coordination.
- Volume and wholesale buyers: The wholesale program rewards makers who have moved into production with better pricing at qualifying volumes.
- Machine buyers: The red Weaver machines are recognized in serious leathercraft shops. If machines are on your list, this is the right place to start that research.
- Beginners stepping up from Tandy: Weaver is consistently recommended as the next step for makers who have outgrown Tandy and want broader selection and better quality.
Reputation Snapshot
Weaver Leather Supply carries a solid reputation across the leathercraft community. Reddit’s r/Leathercraft and r/Leatherworking consistently describe them as reliable and beginner-friendly, with community members noting they are a step up from Tandy in quality and selection. The Facebook page carries 96% recommend across 85 reviews. Customer service is frequently cited as a genuine strength – multiple Reddit threads describe situations where Weaver resolved issues without pushback, including replacing items lost in transit and crediting accounts for fulfillment errors.
The areas that come up in negative feedback are shipping speed and occasional QC variation on leather. Shipping delays are largely attributed to carrier issues rather than Weaver’s fulfillment, and the community consensus is that when there is a problem, Weaver fixes it. The WorthePenny aggregate score of 3.8 reflects a mixed review pool that includes some outlier experiences, but the broader community sentiment is clearly positive.
Pricing and Value Notes
Weaver’s pricing is competitive for the quality level they deliver. The leather is priced above commodity suppliers and below the premium tannery-specific shops, which is appropriate for what you are getting – consistent, reliable leather that performs well across a range of projects. Hardware pricing is particularly competitive, especially at volume.
The wholesale program is worth investigating if you are buying regularly. Qualifying for wholesale pricing requires meeting volume thresholds, but for makers who have moved into production, the savings are meaningful. Check the wholesale / volume pricing page for current qualification requirements. The sale section is also worth a regular check for deals on leather and supplies.
Speed, Shipping, and Returns
Processing Speed: Weaver typically processes orders within 1-3 business days. The Mount Hope, Ohio location puts them in a central-eastern US position that works well for most domestic transit times.
Shipping: Standard and expedited shipping options are available. Community feedback notes that carrier delays in the Ohio area have affected some orders – this is a carrier issue, not a Weaver fulfillment issue. For deadline-sensitive orders, expedited shipping is the safer choice. Check the returns page for current shipping rate information.
Returns: Weaver has a reputation for handling returns and issues fairly. Community members report that problems are resolved without pushback. Review the return policy for current terms before placing a large order. Free return shipping is available for qualifying situations.
Watch Outs
- Shipping delays are carrier-driven: The Ohio distribution area has seen carrier congestion that affects transit times. Factor this in for deadline-sensitive orders and choose expedited shipping when timing matters.
- QC variation on leather: Community feedback notes occasional variation in leather quality, particularly on Hermann Oak stock. Order extra if you need consistent grain and temper across a full project run.
- Wholesale qualification requires volume: The wholesale program has volume thresholds. If you are not yet at production volume, you will pay retail pricing – which is still competitive, but not the best rate available.
- Some tools are entry-level quality: The tool catalog includes a range of quality levels. Community feedback suggests avoiding the lower-end edgers and skiving tools in favor of better alternatives. The leather and hardware are the strong suit.
- Custom hide splitting discontinued: Community feedback notes that Weaver stopped offering custom hide splitting. If you need leather split to a specific thickness, plan to do it yourself or source from a supplier who still offers that service.
Fastest Buying Path
- Start with hardware: If hardware is part of your order, Weaver’s catalog is one of the best places to source it. Lock your hardware specs first and build the rest of the order around them.
- Define your leather specs: Thickness, temper, color, and type before you browse. The catalog is large enough that having clear specs saves significant time.
- Check wholesale eligibility: If you are buying at volume, review the wholesale program requirements before placing a retail order. Qualifying for wholesale changes the math significantly.
- Check the sale section: Weaver runs sales on leather and supplies. Worth a look before committing to full price.
- Order extra leather if color-match matters: Batch variation is real. Buy enough to cover the full project run in one order.
- Choose expedited shipping for deadlines: Standard shipping through the Ohio area can be slow. If timing matters, pay for expedited. Visit Weaver Leather Supply and review their return policy before checkout.
Alternatives
- Rocky Mountain Leather Supply: Strong customer service, wide leather selection, and fast shipping. A solid alternative when you want a broad catalog without the wholesale complexity.
- Springfield Leather: Deep catalog with strong leather and hardware selection. Comparable depth to Weaver with a different regional distribution point.
- Tandy Leather: The starter-friendly option with in-store locations nationwide. Best for beginners and makers who need leather this week from a physical store.
Want to be featured on this page?
Featured and Enhanced placements are available for leather suppliers. We offer a limited number of sponsored spots to reach our dedicated audience of leathercrafters. All sponsored content is clearly labeled to maintain the trust of our readers.
Logos and images are displayed only with supplier permission or sponsorship.
See placement options on the directory page | Contact us about sponsorship