OA Leather Supply Review
Quick Take: A Canadian powerhouse, OA Leather Supply built its reputation on a massive social media presence and a unique business model. They specialize in rare and limited-run leathers, offering custom-sized cuts and detailed video reviews for nearly every hide they sell. This approach, combined with a highly engaged community, makes them a go-to for crafters seeking unique materials and a transparent buying experience.
Maker Angle: This review synthesizes information from dozens of community discussions, social media posts, and direct supplier policies. Our goal is to provide a clear, unbiased picture of what it’s like to buy from OA Leather Supply, from their famous Instagram auctions to the practical realities of shipping from Canada, so you can decide if they are the right fit for your next project.
Quick Jump
Fast Links
Maker Notes
OA Leather Supply operates more like a modern media company than a traditional leather supplier. Their business is built on community engagement, particularly on Instagram, where they run live auctions and showcase new arrivals. The key to a successful purchase is understanding their unique model. Every hide is treated like a unique product, often with its own detailed video review, which allows you to see the leather’s temper, finish, and pull-up before you buy. This significantly reduces the risk of ordering the wrong material.
Because they are based in Canada, makers in the United States should be mindful of shipping thresholds and potential customs fees. OA offers a flat shipping rate for US orders over $250, so it is often more economical to place larger, less frequent orders. Their customer service is widely praised, so don’t hesitate to reach out with questions before committing to a purchase.
Best For
- Hobbyists Seeking Unique Hides: If you are tired of the same standard leathers and want to find something truly unique for a special project, OA is an excellent choice.
- Visual Buyers: For makers who need to see the specific characteristics of a hide before buying, OA’s video reviews are an invaluable resource.
- Community-Oriented Crafters: If you enjoy being part of a larger leathercraft community and participating in events like live auctions, OA’s social media presence is a major draw.
- Makers Needing Custom Sizes: The ability to order quarter, half, or full sides allows for more flexibility and less waste compared to suppliers who only sell full hides.
Reputation Snapshot
OA Leather Supply enjoys an overwhelmingly positive reputation within the leathercraft community. They are widely praised for their exceptional customer service, the unique quality of their leathers, and the transparency of their business practices. The owner, Ian Guenter, is a highly respected figure who has built a loyal following through his direct engagement with customers on social media.
With over 176,000 Instagram followers and a very active Facebook page, they have cultivated the largest and most engaged social media community in the leathercraft world. Any negative feedback is rare and typically relates to the high shipping costs for international customers, which is an unavoidable reality of their Canadian location.
Pricing and Value Notes
While not always the cheapest option, OA Leather Supply provides significant value through its curated selection and unique services. The ability to see a video of the exact hide you are buying minimizes the risk of costly purchasing mistakes. Their practice of offering custom-sized cuts also means you only pay for the amount of leather you actually need.
The best deals are often found during their live Instagram auctions, where rare and premium leathers can be purchased at a discount. For US-based makers, the value proposition is strongest when placing larger orders that meet the $250 threshold for flat-rate shipping.
Speed, Shipping, and Returns
OA Leather Supply offers flat-rate shipping for orders over $75 in Canada ($11 CAD ) and over $250 in the USA ($19 CAD). Their return policy is customer-friendly, offering a replacement or exchange within 5-7 business days if you are not satisfied with a product. This demonstrates a strong commitment to customer satisfaction.
Given their location in Canada, US customers should factor in potential shipping time and customs processing. However, community feedback suggests that their shipping is generally reliable and efficient.
Watch Outs
- Shipping Costs to the US: The $250 threshold for flat-rate shipping to the United States can be a significant hurdle for makers who only need a small amount of leather.
- Fast-Moving Inventory: Due to the rare and limited-run nature of their stock, desirable hides can sell out quickly. If you see something you like, it is best to act fast.
- Customs and Duties: As a Canadian company, orders shipped to the US may be subject to customs fees or duties, which are outside of OA’s control.
- Premium Pricing: Their focus on unique and high-quality leathers means their prices may be higher than some larger, US-based suppliers who deal in more common tannages.
Fastest Buying Path
- Follow on Social Media: Start by following OA Leather Supply on Instagram and Facebook to stay informed about new arrivals and upcoming live auctions.
- Watch the Video Reviews: Before making a purchase, watch the detailed video review for the specific hide you are interested in. This is the best way to assess its true characteristics.
- Consolidate Your Order: To get the most value from shipping, especially to the US, plan your purchases and consolidate them into a single order to meet the flat-rate shipping threshold.
- Contact Customer Service: If you have any questions about a specific hide or shipping, reach out to their highly-praised customer service team for assistance.
Alternatives to OA Leather Supply
- Maverick Leather – A strong option when you want variety and deal-driven buying from a US-based supplier with a large inventory of Horween leathers.
- The Hide House – A good choice for a broader selection and an old-school supplier feel, offering a vast catalog of leathers for various applications.
- Springfield Leather – Useful when you want a large catalog that includes not just leather but also a wide range of tools, hardware, and dyes, catering heavily to the hobbyist market.
Want to be featured on this page?
Featured and Enhanced placements are available for leather suppliers. We offer a limited number of sponsored spots to reach our dedicated audience of leathercrafters. All sponsored content is clearly labeled to maintain the trust of our readers.
Logos and images are displayed only with supplier permission or sponsorship.
See placement options on the directory page | Contact us about sponsorship